Hala Canada English edition
Canada

Canada is headed toward missing its Paris Agreement targets. Why won't the government say so?

Government estimates and environmental studies indicate Canada is on track to miss its Paris Agreement climate targets for 2030, while the federal government avoids saying whether it can meet them.

By Hala Canada News

Translated from Arabic. Read the original بالعربية

Canada is headed toward missing its Paris Agreement targets. Why won't the government say so?

OTTAWA — The federal government is facing growing criticism over its climate policy, after official estimates and independent studies showed it will be difficult to meet targets for cutting greenhouse gas emissions by 2030.

Despite indications that the gap between climate commitments and expected results is widening, the government of Prime Minister Mark Carney continues to stress its commitment to the Paris Agreement on climate change.

However, it is avoiding a direct answer on whether the targets set for 2030 can be met, as it has rolled back a number of environmental measures introduced by previous governments.

Large gap between climate targets and expected results

Canada has committed to cutting greenhouse gas emissions by between 40% and 45% by 2030, compared with 2005 levels.

However, government estimates published in 2025 indicate the country will achieve a reduction of only 28% in the best-case scenario.

Government projections issued in 2023 indicated emissions could be cut by 36%.

The latest estimates also do not take into account the full effect of government decisions to cancel or weaken a number of environmental measures.

These figures point to a growing gap between the stated targets and the policies being applied in practice.

Canada more than 20 years behind its targets

The Canadian Climate Institute, in a study published last September, found that the country may not reach its climate targets set for 2030 until 2050.

The study was based on an analysis of current environmental policies, including the energy cooperation agreement between the federal government and the province of Alberta.

Independent estimates also showed that Canadian emissions rose in 2025, mainly as a result of increased use of natural gas in buildings and electricity generation.

Even so, the institute said the remaining climate policies continue to make a tangible contribution to limiting expected emissions.

Carney government rolls back environmental policies

Over the past year, the federal government has made several decisions that drew criticism from environmental organizations.

The changes included scrapping the mandatory requirement to reach specific shares of electric vehicle sales, and delaying the application of stricter vehicle emissions standards until 2029 at the earliest.

Carney acknowledged last June that Canadian emissions in the coming years will be higher than previously projected.

Changes to industrial climate policy, under the agreement with Alberta, have also raised concerns about the country's ability to accelerate emissions reductions.

Former environment ministers criticize the government

Environment Minister Julie Dabrusin was criticized by former ministers Catherine McKenna and Steven Guilbeault after her remarks at the UN climate conference, COP31, in Türkiye.

The two former ministers said the government's current policies are not consistent with its stated climate commitments.

For its part, Dabrusin's office said Canada remains committed to reaching net-zero emissions by 2050.

It said the government is focusing on clean energy projects, expanding the use of electricity and investing in the low-carbon economy, in cooperation with the provinces and Indigenous peoples.

Possible political and legal consequences

Representatives of Greenpeace Canada and Environmental Defence say that acknowledging the abandonment of the 2030 targets could carry political and legal consequences for the Liberal government.

The government already faces a lawsuit seeking to force it to amend its emissions reduction plan to comply with the Canadian Net-Zero Emissions Accountability Act.

Parliament passed the law in June 2021 with the aim of increasing transparency and holding the government accountable for carrying out its climate commitments.

However, the law does not set direct financial penalties if the stated targets are not met.

Criticism of Canada's performance compared with industrialized countries

An earlier study by the 440 Megatonnes project showed that Canada recorded the weakest performance among G7 countries in cutting emissions compared with 2005 levels.

The average reduction in emissions in the other six countries reached about 32% by 2023, compared with only 8.5% in Canada.

These findings raise questions about Ottawa's ability to maintain its international credibility in climate negotiations.

They also reflect the difficulty of balancing the development of the energy sector with meeting environmental commitments.

Government report reveals additional shortcomings

A report by the Commissioner of the Environment and Sustainable Development, released on October 29, concluded that the government has not set out clear additional measures to close the climate gap.

It also found that some low-carbon government procurement programs had not achieved the required results.

While noting improvements in reporting and oversight mechanisms, the report stressed the need to make the measures being taken to reduce emissions more effective.

Canada is scheduled to submit a report on its 2030 climate targets to the United Nations in December, amid anticipation of the government's official position on the widening gap between its international pledges and the expected results.

More from Hala Canada