Quebec has Canada's longest emergency room stays, Montreal Economic Institute report finds
Quebec has the longest median emergency department stay in Canada at 5 hours 12 minutes, and some Montreal hospitals exceed 14 hours, according to a new report.
Translated from Arabic. Read the original بالعربية
MONTREAL — A new report by the Montreal Economic Institute says Quebec has the longest typical time patients spend in emergency departments among the Canadian provinces for which comparable data were available.
The median length of stay in emergency was five hours and 12 minutes, compared with two hours and 47 minutes in Newfoundland and Labrador, according to the results released Thursday.
The report reflects continuing pressure on hospitals despite higher health spending in recent years. The researchers called for reforms to how services are delivered and for less reliance on emergency departments for less serious cases.
What does five hours and 12 minutes mean?
The indicator measures the period from when a patient is registered in emergency until they leave or are transferred to another department within the hospital.
The figure does not mean every patient waits that long before seeing a doctor. A separate indicator measures the time until the first medical assessment.
Referring to the median means that half of the stays were shorter than the recorded figure and half were longer.
This measure reduces the effect of exceptional cases that may remain in emergency for many hours.
Quebec recorded an increase of 41 minutes compared with 2018, which confirms that the problem is not limited to a temporary rise tied to a particular season.
Laval leads the regions with the longest stays
The comparison within Quebec showed clear differences between regions. Laval ranked first with a median stay of seven hours and 49 minutes, followed by the Laurentides at six hours and 51 minutes, then Montérégie at six hours and 32 minutes.
The Gaspésie region had the shortest stays, at three hours and 22 minutes.
This gap means a patient's experience varies considerably depending on the region and the facility they go to.
At the hospital level, the Albert-Prévost pavilion in Montreal, which specializes in mental health, recorded the longest median stay at 14 hours and 23 minutes.
The Royal Victoria Hospital followed at nine hours and 45 minutes, then Hull Hospital at nine hours and 12 minutes.
Is the situation similar across Canada?
The wait problem is not limited to Quebec. The report found that emergency department stays have lengthened over the past five years in the provinces included in the historical comparison.
Ontario, for example, recorded a slight improvement over the previous year, with the length of stay falling from four hours to about three hours and 54 minutes. The long-term trend, however, remained worrying.
It is important to note that Manitoba and Saskatchewan did not provide the data needed for the study.
The reference periods and methods of reporting data are also not entirely identical across all provinces, which calls for caution when reading their ranking.
Medical assessment is not length of stay
The report uses a second indicator: the time between a patient's registration and the first assessment by a doctor or nurse practitioner.
In the provincial comparison, this indicator was one hour and 21 minutes in Ontario, compared with two hours and nine minutes in Prince Edward Island.
In Quebec, the median time to this assessment rose by about 54.5 per cent over five years, according to the institute.
Separating the two indicators reveals two different aspects of the problem: how quickly a medical assessment begins, and the total time needed to complete the patient's journey through the emergency department.
Proposals to ease pressure on hospitals
Economic analyst Gabriel Giguère said higher spending alone has not succeeded in reducing wait times in Quebec, and he called for organizational changes inspired by the experience of other countries.
The researchers proposed creating different care pathways according to patients' needs, expanding remote medical consultations, and making greater use of the services of nurses and pharmacists.
The report also pointed to urgent care centres for minor cases in France, and to a model that allows some doctors to work in both the public and private sectors under regulated arrangements.
These proposals remain positions put forward by the institute and are not decisions the Quebec government has announced it is adopting.
Patients with serious or life-threatening symptoms should seek emergency care without delay because of the published wait figures.
More from Hala Canada
- KPMG Canada reports cyber incident involving unauthorized access to clients' tax documents
- Carney avoids position on Quebecor's $31-billion bid for Telus, stresses competition
- 61% of Toronto-area residents rate emergency room wait times as bad, poll finds
- Six outcomes of Carney's trip to Asia and Ireland, from Trump meeting to deals with China and the Philippines
- 22 chickens escape from truck in Toronto parking lot as firefighters step in to round them up
- Toronto drug checking program finds new synthetic opioid in fentanyl samples