Hala Canada English edition
Canada

Labour board sides with employee who said God told him not to get COVID-19 vaccine

A federal public servant in Canada has won a religious discrimination case after refusing the COVID-19 vaccine, saying his religious beliefs prevent him from being vaccinated.

By Hala Canada News

Translated from Arabic. Read the original بالعربية

Labour board sides with employee who said God told him not to get COVID-19 vaccine

OTTAWA — A federal government employee was subjected to discrimination on the basis of his religious beliefs after he refused to receive the COVID-19 vaccine, saying his decision was based on his belief that God had commanded him not to be vaccinated.

The case reopens the debate over the relationship between freedom of belief and public health requirements within Canadian government institutions.

It also highlights the continuing legal fallout from decisions the government made during the pandemic, even though years have passed since the mandatory vaccination policy for federal employees was suspended.

How did the mandatory vaccination dispute begin?

On October 6, 2021, the Canadian government introduced a mandatory COVID-19 vaccination policy for employees of the federal public administration, including those working for the Royal Canadian Mounted Police.

The policy covered employees who worked in offices as well as those who performed their duties remotely.

Employees who did not meet the vaccination requirements and had not been granted an approved accommodation faced being placed on administrative leave without pay.

However, the government made it possible to request an exemption for medical or religious reasons, or for other reasons protected by the Canadian Human Rights Act.

When is the refusal of an exemption considered religious discrimination?

The Canadian Human Rights Commission explains that employers are required to consider needs linked to religious beliefs protected by law.

They must look for reasonable accommodations that allow the employee to continue working, unless those accommodations cause undue hardship to the organization.

Factors taken into account include costs, health and safety in the workplace.

This does not mean that an employee's mere declaration of opposition to vaccination for personal reasons automatically gives them the right to a religious exemption.

Each case is assessed independently, based on its circumstances and the evidence submitted.

Earlier decisions in favour of government employees

Last August, media reported on a decision in favour of Christopher Martin, an employee of the Canada Revenue Agency, after the agency rejected his request for a religious exemption.

The Federal Public Sector Labour Relations and Employment Board ordered that he be compensated for the wages and benefits he lost while on leave without pay.

In October, another employee, Michelle Tatti, who worked in passport services, received $5,000 in compensation for the harm caused by the discrimination she experienced.

These decisions concern separate individual cases, with differing circumstances and legal details.

Collective complaints against the government dismissed

By contrast, in December 2025 the board dismissed key parts of the complaints filed by the Public Service Alliance of Canada against the vaccination policy.

The board found that adopting the policy fell within the government's administrative authority, and that administrative leave without pay is not in itself a disciplinary penalty.

On November 10, 2026, the Union of Taxation Employees announced that the alliance had decided to withdraw the remaining collective complaints after reviewing their chances of success.

However, the decision does not prevent individual discrimination complaints from continuing to be heard, and these are being assessed according to each employee's circumstances.

Is vaccination still mandatory?

The Canadian government suspended the mandatory vaccination policy for federal employees effective June 20, 2022, following a review of the country's health situation.

The suspension allowed employees covered by the policy to return to work without having to meet the earlier vaccination requirements.

But the end of the measures did not resolve disputes over lost wages or claims for compensation for discrimination during the period the policy was in force.

What does the decision mean for employees?

These cases underline the importance of examining exemption requests individually, rather than rejecting them automatically or accepting them without scrutiny.

Siding with an employee because of his religious beliefs also does not mean the labour relations board has ruled on the safety or medical effectiveness of COVID-19 vaccines.

The decision concerns the employee's rights and how the government institution handled his case, not a scientific assessment of the vaccine.

Protecting public health and combating discrimination remain two responsibilities that institutions must take into account when setting and carrying out policies.

More from Hala Canada