Hala Canada English edition
Ottawa

Meta says it may consider pulling WhatsApp from Canada if Bill C-22 passes

Company representatives told a Senate committee that the government's amendments to Bill C-22 do not protect encrypted data, while Signal repeated its threat to leave Canada.

By Hala Canada News

Translated from Arabic. Read the original بالعربية

Meta says it may consider pulling WhatsApp from Canada if Bill C-22 passes

OTTAWA — Representatives of Meta said the company would have to "consider" withdrawing encryption services from Canada if the government's lawful access bill, C-22, passes without further amendments. They made the comments in testimony before the Senate national security committee on Monday evening.

The bill requires technology companies to adapt their systems so that all of them can hand over information to investigators under a judicial warrant. It is currently under study in the Senate. Meta's services include Facebook, Instagram and the encrypted messaging app WhatsApp.

Robyn Greene, Meta's director of privacy and public policy, said encrypted information, which is supposed to be seen only by the users exchanging it, remains vulnerable to malicious actors under the bill. She added: "In the end, the Canadian government will impose a law that cannot technically be complied with while continuing to offer secure, end-to-end encrypted services to Canadians."

Asked whether the company would withdraw some of its services, Rachel Curran, head of public policy for Meta Canada, replied that the company would have to "review all of our options." She stressed that withdrawing services is something the company must "consider."

What does the bill contain?

The bill gives the minister the power to issue secret ministerial orders to electronic service providers operating in Canada, asking them to build surveillance and monitoring capabilities into their systems. These orders are first subject to review by the Intelligence Commissioner, an independent quasi-judicial official.

Before the bill was sent to the Senate in June, Public Safety Minister Gary Anandasangaree introduced amendments that set limits on the cases in which companies are required to decrypt information. Another amendment reduced the period for which companies must retain metadata to six months, down from as long as one year. This followed warnings from cybersecurity experts that such data is an attractive target for hackers.

However, Curran told the committee that the government's amendments do not go far enough to protect encrypted data. She explained: "It protected only the core, and did not protect the outer layers that form an essential part of the encryption process."

Signal and Apple join the critics

The encrypted messaging service Signal has repeatedly said it will withdraw from Canada if the bill passes. Its vice-president, Udbhav Tiwari, told the committee: "If we are forced to choose between betraying our users and leaving Canada, we will not compromise on the security of Canadians." Tiwari called on the government to make additional amendments, including explicit safeguards to protect encrypted data.

Apple said earlier this month that the amendments are not sufficient. Its statement said: "We appreciate the efforts to improve C-22, but it could still undermine Apple's ability to deliver the strong privacy and security features our users expect from us, including encryption, at a time when artificial intelligence and other technologies are giving hackers new tools to exploit cybersecurity weaknesses."

The government's position and the privacy commissioner

The government says the bill is necessary to give security agencies the legal tools they need to prevent, investigate and respond to modern crimes, and to protect Canadians. The bill nonetheless continues to face objections. It is the second lawful access bill the government has introduced in this parliamentary session.

Earlier this month, Privacy Commissioner Philippe Dufresne urged the Senate committee to amend the bill further to better protect Canadians' privacy.

The bill lowers the legal threshold that allows security and intelligence agencies to access basic subscriber information, such as names, addresses, phone numbers, email addresses and account numbers. The standard moves from "reasonable grounds to believe" to "reasonable grounds to suspect" that a crime has been or will be committed. Dufresne said the definition of subscriber information, and of the entities that could be asked to hand it over, remain too broad given the lowered threshold.

What does this mean for the Arab community in Canada?

  • The bill is still under study in the Senate and has not yet become law. The testimony did not indicate that any company has actually withdrawn its services.
  • People who use WhatsApp, Instagram, Facebook or Signal to communicate with family in Canada and abroad may wish to follow any official announcement from these companies about their services in Canada.
  • If the bill passes in its current form, access to basic subscriber information, such as name, address, phone number and email address, would require "reasonable grounds to suspect" rather than "to believe."

More from Hala Canada