Quebecor's $31-billion bid for Telus raises concerns about phone bills and competition
Quebecor's roughly $31-billion offer to acquire Telus has prompted warnings that reduced competition could push up telecommunications prices, though no increase is confirmed.
Translated from Arabic. Read the original بالعربية
MONTREAL — A major offer by Quebecor to acquire Telus has raised concerns about the future of mobile and internet prices, amid warnings that the deal could reduce competition and lead to higher monthly bills for consumers.
Montreal-based Quebecor unveiled a proposal on Monday, Nov. 16, to acquire Vancouver-based Telus in a cash-and-stock deal valued at about $31 billion.
The potential deal raises questions about its effect on millions of subscribers, particularly given that a small number of large companies dominate Canada's telecommunications sector.
Warnings of higher phone bills in Canada
Eric Bohlin, a professor of communications at Western University's Ivey Business School, warned that a merger of the two companies could reduce the number of main competitors from four to three.
He explained that reduced competition could create pressure that pushes prices higher, even if the increases do not appear immediately after the deal is completed.
Rogers, Bell and Telus currently compete for a large share of the market, while Quebecor, through its brands, seeks to offer lower-cost alternatives.
Experts say the disappearance of an independent competitor could give the remaining companies greater power to control prices in the future.
Could the merger lower prices?
Despite the concerns, some analysts say the deal could bring potential benefits to consumers.
David McFadgen, managing director of institutional research at ATB Cormark Capital Markets, said that Quebecor owning a broader network could reduce the costs of operating its services.
The company currently relies on buying access to competitors' networks outside Quebec, while Telus is in a similar position in parts of the province.
The merger could reduce these expenses, giving the new company an opportunity to offer more competitive plans.
However, it is not guaranteed that operating savings would be turned into real price cuts for subscribers.
Future of Freedom Mobile raises concern
One of the main obstacles centres on Freedom Mobile, which Quebecor acquired in 2023.
That acquisition came as a condition of approval for the merger of Rogers and Shaw, a deal valued at $26 billion.
The aim was to preserve an additional competitor that could offer lower prices and take on the large companies.
Carol Liao, a law professor at the University of British Columbia, said regulators will examine the merger's effect on the choices available to consumers.
Authorities could require the sale of some wireless assets to ensure competition continues, similar to the earlier conditions attached to the Rogers-Shaw merger.
Why does Quebecor want to buy Telus?
Quebecor is seeking to expand its national reach and take advantage of Telus's strong network in Western Canada.
Telus faces challenges tied to the growth of some of its digital, health and agriculture businesses, along with pressure on its share value.
The company's stock had fallen 32 per cent from the start of the year to last Friday, before rising 12.8 per cent on Monday following the announcement of the offer.
Analysts say these circumstances make Telus an attractive acquisition target.
Will the Canadian government approve the deal?
Regulatory approvals remain one of the biggest obstacles to completing the deal, particularly given concerns about market concentration.
Quebecor says the merged company would be able to compete more strongly with Rogers and Bell and invest in developing telecommunications infrastructure.
But officials will need guarantees regarding prices and the continuation of competition.
The sector also faces new challenges from satellite internet services, including Elon Musk's Starlink.
So far, the deal remains only a non-binding proposal, and no final decision on approving it has been issued.
As a result, there is no confirmed increase in subscribers' bills as a result of this offer, but the future of prices will depend on the terms of any final agreement and the related regulatory decisions.
More from Hala Canada
- Canadian home sales fall 10.6% year over year in October; average price drops to $678,584
- Experts warn parliamentary committee that AI pricing could raise grocery costs for some Canadians
- 54% of Toronto residents want Sankofa Square's old name restored
- Canadians plan holiday spending despite financial pressure, CPA Canada survey finds
- Trillium College resumes classes for students who can pay, keeps others out of the classroom
- Ontario real estate regulator issues guidance on AI-edited home photos in listings