Experts warn parliamentary committee that AI pricing could raise grocery costs for some Canadians
Experts told a House of Commons committee that AI-driven pricing based on personal data and shopping habits could mean some consumers pay more than others for the same groceries.
Translated from Arabic. Read the original بالعربية
OTTAWA — Experts have warned a Canadian parliamentary committee that the use of artificial intelligence to set food prices could lead to higher prices for some consumers, particularly people who follow specific diets for health or religious reasons.
The warnings come amid growing concern about what is known as "surveillance pricing," a practice that relies on analyzing personal data and shopping habits to determine the price each consumer might pay for the same product.
During a House of Commons ethics committee hearing on Monday, Nov. 16, MPs discussed the possible effects of these technologies on market fairness, privacy and families' ability to afford food.
How could AI raise grocery prices?
Sarah Louise Roder, an assistant professor at the Food and Agriculture Institute at the University of the Fraser Valley, explained that algorithmic pricing systems can analyze consumers' purchases and infer which products they need on an ongoing basis.
She added that people with limited food choices could be more likely to pay high prices, because algorithms may conclude they are willing to pay more for certain products.
Her remarks were in response to a question from Liberal MP Fares Al Soud, who noted that some consumers avoid certain foods for religious or health reasons.
The MP asked whether this information could be exploited to raise prices for Muslims, Jews and Hindus, as well as for people with health conditions that require special diets.
Roder said these risks are real, noting that similar practices have been observed in the United States.
Could prices vary by time of day and weather?
The committee also discussed electronic shelf labels, which are starting to replace traditional paper price tags in some stores.
Roder said Canadian retailers have stated that they are not using these labels to impose personalized prices based on customer surveillance.
However, the technology allows prices to be adjusted quickly based on various factors, such as raising the price of coffee in the morning or the price of ice cream on hot days.
She stressed that applying individual pricing inside stores would require collecting additional data on shoppers, and possibly using monitoring tools in the aisles.
Price differences of up to 23 per cent
Keldon Bester, executive director of the Canadian Anti-Monopoly Project, said U.S. research has found significant differences in prices displayed on the Instacart platform.
According to a study by Consumer Reports and the Groundwork Collaborative, some customers paid up to 23 per cent more than others during algorithmic pricing experiments.
The company said, however, that those experiments ended about a year ago, that they did not rely on monitoring personal data to set individual prices, and that it is committed to not using surveillance pricing.
Bester said the Competition Bureau has identified at least 60 companies offering algorithmic pricing services to clients in Canada.
Concerns about exploiting families' needs
Renjie Butalid, a co-founder of the Montreal AI Ethics Institute, cautioned against confusing pricing tied to market conditions with pricing that exploits personal information.
He gave the example of a parent who urgently needs to buy infant formula, explaining that smart systems could take advantage of the parent's limited options to charge a higher price.
Butalid called for a general ban on practices that use personal or behavioural data to set different prices for each consumer.
Users' data under watch
Emily Osborne, a researcher at the Canadian SHIELD Institute, warned about the lack of transparency in these systems.
She explained that companies may rely on a user's IP address, device type and postal code, as well as behaviour during online shopping.
Even mouse movements can be analyzed to infer how urgently a consumer wants to complete a purchase.
Osborne said the lack of information about how prices are set makes it harder to compare offers and plan a household budget.
Will the federal government step in?
The Liberal government said its proposed privacy bill could provide tools to address surveillance pricing, although the practice is not explicitly mentioned in the bill's text.
Experts are calling for clear rules to ensure consumers' sensitive data is not exploited, along with greater transparency in how prices are set.
The discussions come as Canadian households face ongoing pressure from the cost of living, which adds to the importance of protecting consumers from unfair pricing practices.
The challenge for lawmakers remains striking a balance between using technology to improve market efficiency and preventing personal data from becoming a means of increasing the financial burden on citizens.
More from Hala Canada
- Quebecor's $31-billion bid for Telus raises concerns about phone bills and competition
- Canadian home sales fall 10.6% year over year in October; average price drops to $678,584
- 54% of Toronto residents want Sankofa Square's old name restored
- Canadians plan holiday spending despite financial pressure, CPA Canada survey finds
- Trillium College resumes classes for students who can pay, keeps others out of the classroom
- Ontario real estate regulator issues guidance on AI-edited home photos in listings